Since its January release, the drama When the Stars Gossip has become a global point of contention. With top stars Lee Min Ho and Gong Hyo Jin, the show was expected to be a major hit for Korean television. However, reality proved otherwise.
Main Plot and Controversies Surrounding the Show
Unique Setting but Shallow Storyline
When the Stars Gossip revolves around a fateful meeting between a tourist and an astronaut on a space station. Dr. Gong Ryong (played by Lee Min Ho) is a dedicated obstetrician, while Eve Kim (portrayed by Gong Hyo Jin) is a passionate scientist.
The show gained attention for its rare theme in Korean dramas: exploring the lives of scientists in outer space. Yet, instead of delving into scientific elements and authentic emotions, the script fell into the cliché of romantic dramas. Many viewers found the plot bland, lacking highlights, and failing to differentiate itself from similar works.
Controversial scene between the two main characters (Image: Naver)
The Space Sex Scene: A Major Downfall
One of the most controversial scenes is the intimate moment between Eve Kim and Gong Ryong in the harsh environment of space. When the engine module explodes and the solar energy converter malfunctions, the two characters are forced to share a tent to survive the cold and lack of oxygen.
This scene was heavily criticized for its unrealistic visual effects, provocative dialogue, and crude execution. One viewer commented, “The space romance scene felt like it was taking place inside a fertilized egg. I really don’t understand the director’s vision.” Many called it “the worst sex scene in the history of Korean TV dramas.”
Low-rated intimate scene from the drama (Image: Naver)
Record-Low Ratings
Not only did the show fail content-wise, but When the Stars Gossip also disappointed broadcasters with record-low ratings. Episode 5 attracted just 1.8% viewership, an alarming figure for a project budgeted at $34 million. South Korean media attributed the failure to overuse of controversial scenes and poor-quality special effects.
Expectations and Disappointments Regarding the Lead Actors
Lee Min Ho: An Unsuccessful Return
Lee Min Ho, famous for hits like Boys Over Flowers, The Heirs, and Blue Sea Legend, was expected to deliver a breakthrough performance in When the Stars Gossip. He shared in a press conference, “I want to challenge new roles to showcase my diverse acting skills.”
However, Lee Min Ho’s monotonous acting style continued to receive criticism. His character, Gong Ryong, lacked depth and failed to leave a strong impression. This disappointment was especially pronounced given high expectations for his return to small screen after a long hiatus.
Lee Min Ho as Dr. Gong Ryong (Image: Osen)
Gong Hyo Jin: Talent Wasted
Veteran actress Gong Hyo Jin also could not salvage the show from its failures. Despite her commendable portrayal of Eve Kim, the weak script and superficial character development prevented her from fully showcasing her talents.
Conclusion and Lessons Learned
When the Stars Gossip serves as a prime example of how significant investment does not guarantee quality content. Despite featuring renowned actors and a unique theme, the drama failed due to a shallow storyline, poor special effects, and inappropriate use of controversial scenes.
This serves as a reminder to Korean filmmakers: to create successful works, focus on content, acting, and the audience experience rather than chasing superficial elements. Share your thoughts on the drama and stay tuned for more educational and entertainment updates on COCC-EDU-VN!
Sources:
